From books

The methods can be perfectly rational while the goal they serve is entirely mad.

Herman Melville · Moby Dick · 1851 · capitolul 411 minute readpublic domain
All my means are sane, my motive and my object mad.Herman Melville · Moby Dick · 1851 · capitolul 41

A rigorous method guarantees nothing about the direction — it can even mask a mad one for years.

Ahab admits with lucidity the split between instrument and aim: the navigation, the calculations, the crew all function correctly, yet serve an obsession. It is a portrait of instrumental reason, which does not judge ends, only executes them. A person can be impeccably competent in the service of a destructive project, and competence itself hides the madness of the goal. The rigor of the method guarantees nothing about the health of the direction; it can mask it for years.

Why it mattersIt warns anyone pursuing a goal efficiently without having reexamined it lately, from a career consuming a life to a project that has become an obsession.

Rational methodsUnverified goalObsession efficientlyexecutedMadness masked
Sound methods don't judge the goal; they blindly execute it.

Shelves

Back to the feed