From books

Human nature is too vast and contradictory for any tidy scheme; a speaker wishes he could shrink it into something orderly.

Feodor Dostoievski · Frații Karamazov · 1880 · Cartea III, capitolul 3, «Confesiunea unui om ardent. În versuri1 minute readpublic domain
Man is broad, too broad, I would narrow him.Feodor Dostoievski · Frații Karamazov · 1880 · Cartea III, capitolul 3, «Confesiunea unui om ardent. În versuri

Whoever wants man narrower is fleeing his own breadth, not solving it.

The line admits that a person holds at once the desire for good and for destruction, faith and doubt, humility and pride. It is spoken by someone exhausted by this breadth who would prefer a narrow, comfortable definition, even a false one. The irony is that the wish to narrow man is itself part of his breadth: the craving for order belongs to the contradiction too. Accepting breadth lets you understand your failures without losing your aspirations; denying it leaves you in constant shame.

Why it mattersUseful when you judge people (or yourself) as simply good or bad: human reality is wider than labels.

narrow, orderlymanacceptingcontradictionwide,contradictory man
The spectrum between the comfort of schemes and man's real breadth

Shelves

Back to the feed