Current Patterns of Parental Authority

1 card

1. 01

   Demandingness and warmth are not two ends of one axis but two separate axes — and the combination that does best in the data is demanding and warm at once, not a compromise between them.

   Current Patterns of Parental Authority · 1971

   Demandingness and warmth are two independent axes, not the two ends of one.

   Baumrind's lasting contribution is a distinction that looks banal and changes everything: how much you demand of a child and how responsive you are to them are independent measures. Crossed, they give four boxes. Authoritarian: demands much, responds little — rules without explanation, obedience as the goal. Permissive: responds much, demands little — warmth without limits. Uninvolved: little of either. Authoritative: demands much and responds much — high standards, explained, negotiable at the edges, held with warmth. In her studies and in later replications, the last combination was consistently associated with better outcomes: social competence, emotional regulation, school results. Two honest qualifications. First, these are population correlations, not guaranteed recipes for a particular child. Second, the effect is not culturally uniform: several studies of East Asian families and of African-American communities found that firmer control does not carry the same costs when the child reads it as care rather than hostility. The meaning assigned matters at least as much as the behaviour.

   “The authoritative parent directs the child's activity in a rational, issue-oriented manner; she encourages verbal give and take and shares with the child the reasoning behind her policy.”

   Open the card →