Method
Research ledger: what we tested and what failed
Most ideas we test do not hold. We write them down the same way as the ones that do, because a hidden negative result makes the next positive one worth nothing.
10 tests listed here; 7 were not confirmed.
How a test is run
- The decision rule is written and sealed before the run: what is measured, on which period, what threshold means «confirmed».
- The verification period is looked at once. What has already been looked at is recorded, so it is not reused as fresh evidence.
- Trading costs are inside the figure. An effect that disappears after costs is a negative result.
- The verdict uses fixed words: not confirmed, undecided, correlated. «Causes» is never written.
- BE-1not confirmed
Can a ternary-weight embedding model (BitNet-embedding-0.6B) replace the production model on Romanian retrieval?
Lower nDCG@10 on all three Romanian sets (−0.106 / −0.057 / −0.291, every interval below the −0.02 margin) at 0.25–0.46× the speed on 3 threads. Nothing was changed.
- Q-11not confirmed
Does buying only around the new moon add return or cut the losses of a stock portfolio?
−1.44 percentage points a year against the same strategy without the rule (interval −3.09…−0.51); the worst month is identical.
Replicates: Dichev & Janes 2003; Yuan, Zheng & Zhu 2006
- SL-1open
Do stocks with a large earnings surprise beat the index over 60 sessions more often than not?
46 % (150 of 324, interval 41–52 %): mean +0.9 points, median −2.0. Below half, so we say so; it is now judged prospectively.
- EL-1nothing certain
Does the US stock market react differently depending on which party wins the election?
S&P, 49 elections from 1928 to 2024: the Republican − Democrat gap on the next day is +0.51 points, t 0.91 — nothing certain. Firms follow the party they fund (t 3.21), but the result is fragile and is gone overnight.
- L-4holds
Does post-earnings-announcement drift still exist: the top decile of surprise against consensus, held for 60 sessions?
On the validation period, +2.33 % against the universe (t 3.0). The only established strategy we tested that still holds.
Replicates: Bernard & Thomas 1989
- L-1…3not confirmed
Do three effects from the literature still work: the volume premium, residual reversal and residual momentum?
−0.24 % / −1.29 % (t −3.8) / −0.05 % a month against the universe. None is confirmed; the effects have decayed.
Replicates: Gervais, Kaniel & Mingelgrin 2001; Jegadeesh 1990; Blitz, Huij & Martens 2011
- E-3not confirmed
Does the reversal after a volume spike, described on a small group of stocks, hold across the whole market?
It reproduces on the original group (+8.7 %). Across the market it loses: −10.5 % a year for the reversal, −23.3 % a year for the continuation.
- N-3not confirmed
Do volume patterns alone (accumulation, breakout, a high on volume) predict returns?
All negative after costs; the volume breakout loses 233 basis points in 20 sessions (t −4.5).
- N-2not confirmed
Do press stories and rumours come before large price moves?
Only 6.7 % of moves of at least 8 % have a headline in the 10 days before; the anticipation lift is about 1, which is none.
- EQ-P3not confirmed
Does a stock that is «cheap» by our own valuation formulas beat the market?
The rank correlation on the held-out period is negative (−0.09…−0.10). The valuation bands are not published as a signal.
The list is a selection: tests that revisit a published idea on public market data, plus model evaluations. It is not investment advice and no strategy here trades money.
The published forecasts have their own ledger, with a Brier score →
How to cite this page
Plain
olivLaw, «Research ledger: what we tested and what failed», November 19, 2026, https://olivlaw.com/en/eu/learning/registru (accessed November 20, 2026).
APA
olivLaw. (2026, November 19). Research ledger: what we tested and what failed. https://olivlaw.com/en/eu/learning/registru
BibTeX
@misc{olivlaw-2026-registru,
author = {{olivLaw}},
title = {Research ledger: what we tested and what failed},
year = {2026},
howpublished = {\url{https://olivlaw.com/en/eu/learning/registru}},
note = {Accessed 2026-11-20},
}The texts are produced by olivLaw's AI pipeline; the author of record is the organisation.