olivlaw

From books

No culture calls its violence against children violence: it calls it upbringing, and the child is taught not merely to endure it but to agree with it — and that agreement is exactly what makes it pass on.

Alice Miller · Am Anfang war Erziehung (Pentru binele tău) · 1980 · Alice Miller, «Am Anfang war Erziehung» (1980), tradusă în engleză ca «For Your Own Good» — redare a tezei centrale, necolaționată pe ediție2 minutes read
“Cruelty towards the child has always been carried out in the name of upbringing and for the child's own good.”Alice Miller · Am Anfang war Erziehung (Pentru binele tău) · 1980 · Alice Miller, «Am Anfang war Erziehung» (1980), tradusă în engleză ca «For Your Own Good» — redare a tezei centrale, necolaționată pe ediție

Violence against a child is passed on not by the blow but by the agreement demanded of them afterwards.

Miller read the child-rearing manuals of the German-speaking world of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries and found a coherent system, which she called poisonous pedagogy. Its rules: the child's will must be broken as early as possible; obedience must be obtained without the child understanding the reason; the parent is always right; and everything done is for the child's own good. The part that interested her is not the blow but what is required after it — the child must not be upset, must ask forgiveness, sometimes must say thank you. That is how one learns that the person who loves you is the person who hurts you, and that your anger at them is illegitimate. The anger does not vanish; it changes address, towards the weaker or towards the self. Romanian has a version of brutal concision, the beating is torn from heaven, which does exactly what Miller describes: it moves violence into the sacred register, where it can no longer be argued with. Miller was criticised for monocausality — explaining too much through one mechanism — but the description of the cultural justification has held.

Miller notices something subtler than the blow: what comes after. The child is not only punished but required to make peace with the punishment. Not to be sad, to say he understands, sometimes even to say thank you. This is where everything is decided. If his anger were acknowledged as legitimate, the chain would break. But because his agreement is demanded, he learns to betray his own feelings. Years later, the adult repeats the very formula his parents demanded: I was hit and it did me good. It is not a memory of the fact but a restaging of the obligation. A familiar case: someone laughs while telling how he was sent to fetch the stick himself. The laughter is the second half of the punishment, the part that makes it acceptable. The next question is what would happen if, just once, someone said: no, that was not for my own good.

Why it matters Because it shows why the argument «I was beaten too and I turned out fine» is not evidence but a symptom: it is precisely the agreement the system requires in order to reproduce itself for one more generation.

the blow,calledthe demandforangerbecomesthe adultjustifies

← Back to the feed