Author
Henry Farrell și Abraham L. Newman
1 reading card from 1 book · 2019.
1 card
Weaponized Interdependence: How Global Economic Networks Shape State Coercion · 2019
Whoever controls the node through which flows pass can see everything that passes and cut anyone off, at the price of losing its own centrality.
In 1945, in National Power and the Structure of Foreign Trade, Albert Hirschman showed that trade between a large country and a small one is not symmetric: the small one loses more if the relationship breaks, and the large partner can turn that asymmetry into influence. Henry Farrell and Abraham Newman moved the idea from pairs of states to networks. In Weaponized Interdependence (International Security, 2019) they argue that the global economy has central nodes, such as bank messaging, dollar clearing or semiconductor production. The state with jurisdiction over a node gains two powers: the panopticon effect, meaning it can see the flows that pass through it, and the chokepoint effect, meaning it can cut an adversary off. The mechanism needs an asymmetric network, jurisdiction over the node and domestic institutions willing to act. SWIFT, a Belgian messaging cooperative, disconnected Iranian banks targeted by European Union sanctions in March 2012. In February 2022 Western governments immobilised part of the Bank of Russia's reserves, about 300 billion dollars by their own estimates, out of a total of roughly 630 billion. A node is not eternal: every use shows the target how costly it is to depend on it. The limits lie exactly there. Alternatives (local payment systems, settlement in other currencies, reserves held in gold) raise the cost for whoever uses the weapon, and a node used too often loses its centrality. For the forecaster, the useful question is not ‘will state X use the weapon?’ but who has jurisdiction over the node, how quickly the target can replace it and what the issuer loses if it does. Capacity and decision are different things.
“Increasingly, states are employing global economic networks to fulfill their strategic objectives.”